Graphics Feedback Requested

[Zizka]

Could you please provide criticism for this:

 

[HeWhoShallNotBeNamed]

I really like this. The walls being discolored in places where posters/signs used to be is a good touch. The only complaint I'd have is that the two areas that I'm assuming are doors on the bottom half of the horizontal hall (where the mats are) could be indented like the entrances on the vertical hallway. You could also have different colored doormats to mix things up, but that may or may not make sense depending on what type of building this is. Something like a research facility or even a school would have everything be one color, whereas in an apartment building it would be up to each individual resident.

 

[Toque]

I agree with the door mats. Some doors may not even have one.
Fire extinguishers are usually not that high on a wall.

I like it.

 

[Evanski]

Heres my edits

made the outside color darker to make your eyes focus on the floor
rotated the door mat at the bottom to match with the orientation of the door
made the stains on the wall's where posters once hanged more smudgy
removed the 6 from the wall and put it on the door (figured it was a sign but looked like a wall stain might be a removed sign?)
cleaned up a few loose pixels in the lower left of the void

all in all I really like what youve done

 

[Lance Klepp]

Well thought out with the subtle attention to detail in here.

I agree that the fire extinguisher wouldn't be up high on a wall. Perhaps store it on the floor by the fire exit door. Another neat touch would be a red box for alarming a fire somewhere on the other end of the hallway... Not essential though, unless it's about a fire? Ha.

The green border at the top... What does that represent? I just find that confusing, when you have a yellow border that is similar on the walls below. Are they both supposed to be the top surface of the wall, i.e. top down? Just a minor observation.

Lastly, the lighting is top down on everything apart from the elevator. The base of the doors are darker. Not sure if flipping the doors vertically would fix it. From the current view, it could be mistaken for twin beds sandwiched together ha I mean that it the lightest of jokes.

I hope you can take constructive criticism. You've helped me massively. Just wanna push you to iron out the little differences to help improve your work.

Obviously take from my comments what applies.
Keep at it!


Edit:

Thinking about it, lights reflect off metal, so the elevator doors technically look right. I think it's just the dark section at the base just appears a bit thick.

Managed to zoom in and noticed the wear on the floor at the top where the wood shows through. Could add some more of this detail to the vertical hallway, as in comparison, the vertical seems less messy.

 

[Rayek]

Home alone with the flu and a migraine. So saw this while browsing, and reworked it a bit to kill time.



"Welcome to the Hotel California
Such a lovely place (Such a lovely place)
Such a lovely face
Plenty of room at the Hotel California
Any time of year (Any time of year)
You can find it here"

"Last thing I remember, I was
Running for the door
I had to find the passage back
To the place I was before
"Relax," said the night man
"We are programmed to receive
You can check out any time you like
But you can never leave!"

 

[pixeltroid]

Could you please provide criticism for this:

Looks good. nice details on the walls and doors.

But I feel the floor tiles are too jarring.

Make the outside color darker....as shown in the post above mine.

 

[Zizka]

I think the reason why the floor comes across as too jarring is because the saturation is still too high and so is the contrast. That’s something which is also bothering me, rest assured.